Lecture 14 heuristic evaluation why and how hci course. As we approach formal usability testing of the engineering for change w eb site. In general, heuristic evaluations are easy to conduct, inexpensive and provide feedback quickly. How to conduct a heuristic evaluation heuristic evaluation nielsen and molich, 1990. Though they date back to the 90s, these general rules of thumb are still valid and are used today.
More accessible explanation of usability heuristics along with concrete examples. To help answer these questions, we conducted a heuristic evaluation and usability test to see how the different evaluation methods compared. It specifically involves evaluators examining the interface and judging its compliance with recognized usability principles the heuristics. The analysis results in a list of potential usability issues. Nielsen 1994 is a usability engineering method for finding the usability problems in a user interface design so that they can be attended to as part of an iterative design process. Heuristic evaluation explained with examples what, how. Aug 18, 2016 one of the pioneers who tried to objectively evaluate the user experience on digital platforms is jakob nielsen with his heuristic evaluation.
Kelley martin, usability testing coordinator references neilson norman group. Oct 16, 2014 heuristic evaluation is a process, where evaluators, aka user experience specialists, go through the interface of a website, perform various tasks in order to identify usability issues that need to be fixed for a smoother user experience. Heuristic evaluation discount usability testing adapted from material by marti hearst, loren terveen evaluating ui designs usability testing is a major technique formal techniques require users, rigid control experiments, statistical analysis discount methods. Heuristic evaluation is a method that ensures user research is implemented in ways that are most usable, delightful and natural to users. Phases of heuristic evaluation 1 preevaluation training give evaluators needed domain knowledge and information on the scenario 2 evaluation individuals evaluate and then aggregate results 3 severity rating determine how severe each problem is priority 4. The user can download it in the form of word document. Evaluation enter your observation and evaluation of the degree to which this heuristic has been satisfied. May 11, 2016 heuristic evaluations are no substitute for usability testing, but they can help improve the potential of usability tests if theyre used in conjunction.
I found that a total sample of 148 he evaluators 80% power. Online manuals in pdf format and online help that includes a table of. University libraries heuristic evaluation checklist umkc university libraries usability team. Evaluating collaborative technologies used by academics. Heuristic list seemed the most appropriate for analysing tasks run on form sections of the website.
In general, heuristic evaluation is a usability engineering method for finding usability problems in a user interface design very useful when examining an interface into an iterative design process. Sep 03, 2001 heuristic evaluation is known to find more than 90% of usability problems if its performed by 3 to 5 experienced people but remember, one evaluator is better than none. Similar to heuristic evaluation in that usability is evaluated without feedback from representative users. This technique is based on following a given set of heuristics, which are. Heuristic analysis how to run a usability evaluation toptal. As the definition of heuristic evaluation by the interaction design foundation explains heuristic evaluation is a usability engineering method for finding. We conducted usability assessments 4, 9 on the charting interfaces of working demonstration versions of dentrix version 10. Mental shortcuts can be both beneficial and costly. Heuristic evaluation has the potential to be a valuable evaluation tool for games since it does not make assumptions about tasks and about the purpose of an application. After you describe the example, discuss a better way of thinking. Training evaluators takes about a week on average, not including the time it takes to. Your stepbystep guide to heuristic evaluation in ux design. A heuristic evaluation is a usability inspection technique where one or a number of usability experts evaluate the user interface of a product for example a website against a set of heuristic principles also known as heuristics. The objective of a heuristic evaluation is to 1 define and document usability and design issues based on established human factors principles, 2 identify pain points in the design, and 3 any safety risks and concerns.
Quantitative analysis in a heuristic evaluation experiment. The project team evaluated the website from a chinese users point of view. You can use the heuristic evaluation forms provided on this page to conduct this assessment, and. A heuristic evaluation is a way to test whether a website is user friendly. A personal journey of acculturation and identity reconstruction ivana djuraskovic and nancy arthur university of calgary, calgary, alberta, canada heuristic methodology attempts to discover the nature and meaning of phenomenon through internal selfsearch, exploration, and discovery. Phases of heuristic evaluation 1 pre evaluation training give evaluators needed domain knowledge and information on the scenario 2 evaluation individuals evaluate and then aggregate results 3 severity rating determine how severe each problem is priority 4 debriefing discuss the outcome with design team. Download limit exceeded you have exceeded your daily download allowance. These heuristics should be viewed as a work in progress and fur.
A heuristic evaluation is a usability inspection method for computer software that helps to identify usability problems in the user interface ui design. Comparative study of heuristic evaluation and usability. Heuristic evaluation may identify more minor issues and fewer major issues than would be identified in a thinkaloud usability test jeffries and desurvire, 1992. University libraries heuristic evaluation checklist. This phase three report provides findings and recommendations from the heuristic evaluation as they relate. You can rely on specific examples from, the lives of people you know, the media, books, or movies.
An introduction to heuristic evaluation by fabio muniz a heuristic evaluation is a usability inspection technique where one or a number of usability experts evaluate the user interface of a product for example a website against a set of heuristic principles also known as heuristics. Structured heuristic evaluation of online documentation teced. Heuristic evaluation is known to find more than 90% of usability problems if its performed by 3 to 5 experienced people but remember, one evaluator is better than none. Sep 06, 2012 heuristic evaluation and usability testing. Heuristic evaluation does not replace user research. Speak the users language, with words, phrases and concepts familiar to the user, rather than systemoriented terms.
This report provides a detailed analysis of the heuristic evaluation. The first number in the table refers to the number of the issue as it appears in the complete heuristic evaluation list in the appendix. Heuristic evaluation page 3 of 20 hufflepuff team 6120usability testing september 29, 2011. Heuristic evaluation detects usability issues that can be classified by severity. Just like ux, heuristic evaluation is also very contextual. A larger sample size than the one used in the study would also. Heuristic evaluation a step by step guide article sitepoint. Pdf heuristic evaluation of online documentation using. The findings from the evaluation will be used to design appropriate scenarios for the usability test. Pdf heuristic evaluation of website attractiveness and. Heuristic evaluation is an inspection technique that gives evaluators significant freedom in how they conduct the evaluation 24. Heuristic evaluation is a type of usability inspection method.
An introduction to heuristic evaluation usability geek. Paper presented at the acm chi90 conference on human factors in computing systems, seattle, wa. It involves having a small set of evaluators examining the interface and judges its compliance with recognized usability principles the heuristics. Press coverage as a heuristic guide for social decisionmaking about sexual offenders craig a. Heuristic evaluation of two travel websites wendy bravo. Neither is it a cognitive walkthrough, which is a usability inspection. In complex interfaces, a small number of evaluators may not find a majority of the problems in. Heuristic evaluation is one of the most actively used techniques for analyzing usability, as it is quick and inexpensive. In this document, the methods section describes the process used by our team to conduct the heuristic evaluation. A heuristic evaluation should not replace usability testing.
Romanycia information services, engineering and planning, guy canada, calgary, alta. An appraisal of published usability evaluations of. Unlike usertesting, where the site or prototype is evaluated by users, in a heuristic evaluation the site is evaluated by usability experts. Each participant used only one software package and worked through nine. Heuristic evaluation articles, videos, reports, training. This method evaluates a user interface by inspecting the interface and critiquing the design. Windows which does not allow the user to actually edit the document. Visibility of system status the system should always keep user informed about what is going on, through appropriate feedback within reasonable time. A guide to conducting a heuristic evaluation optimal workshop. It helps to identify many kinds of user experience problems and is conducted against a set of design principles also known as heuristics hence the name. Method figure 1 presents the protocol we developed for the heuristic evaluation of elearning programs. Press coverage as a heuristic guide for social decision. Hogue1 1university of lincoln uk corresponding author. See more ideas about user interface, design thinking and user experience design.
Nov 08, 2014 a heuristic evaluation is a usability inspection method for computer software that helps to identify usability problems in the user interface ui design. Heuristic evaluation of online documentation using. This report describes the heuristic evaluation process and findings for apples itunes digital music application. Four inspectors 2 experts and 2 novices independently examined each. Expert heuristic evaluation interface analysis associates. In this article, i attempt to explain these 10 rules in common language with examples. Heuristic evaluations were introduced by nielsen and molich in 1990 in the influential paper heuristic evaluation of user interfaces and later assembled as part of a book nielsen 1994. A heuristic evaluation is not a oneonone moderated test. Heuristic evaluation is a good method of identifying both major and minor problems with an interface, but the lists of usability problems found by heuristic evaluation will tend to be dominated by minor problems, which is one reason severity ratings form a useful supplement to the method. Usability and instructional design heuristics for e. The heuristic evaluation approach encompasses the usability of collaborative technologies, ease of learning, and the. Heuristic evaluations are no substitute for usability testing, but they can help improve the potential of usability tests if theyre used in conjunction. There are plenty of sets of guidelines to choose from sometimes it seems like every usability researcher has their own set of heuristics. May 24, 2017 a heuristic evaluation is an inspection method in which you systematically apply heuristics qualitative guidelines to find and explain problems.
We recently reported on a heuristic evaluation of the budget and enterprise websites. For the heuristic evaluation study, a set of ten heuristics published by jakob nielsen was used to evaluate the four dental cprs. The purpose of this heuristic evaluation is to discover any potential usability weaknesses that might confuse users. In this paper, you are to find one benefit and one disadvantage associated with both the availability heuristic and the representative heuristic. This phase three report provides findings and recommendations from the heuristic evaluation as they relate to users needs and goals. Jakob nielsen explains the heuristic evaluation method, which allows you to judge a user interface design based on 10 wellproven general principles for humancomputer interaction. A heuristic evaluation is an inspection method in which you systematically apply heuristics qualitative guidelines to find and explain problems. Key findings 24 conclusion 28 heuristic evaluation overview for. Heuristic evaluation involves having a small set of evaluators examine the interface and judge its compliance with recognized usability principles the heuristics. It begins with summary information describing the product and its target population, and then continues with an overview of the heuristic evaluation technique in general.
Heuristic evaluation might be relatively timeconsuming when compared to other quick and dirty inspection methods, such as simple walkthroughs with a small sample of users. Figure 2 lists the fifteen usability and instructional design heuristics. A heuristic evaluation first comprises of a specific task or scope that the leader and participating evaluators must take into account while navigating the website. Heuristicbased user interface evaluation at nanyang. Dfx file is the starting point for all analyses in syntax2d. Also, the author has defined grouped components of heuristic evaluation attributes.
1401 822 1199 477 1620 1394 53 645 700 1175 788 1399 797 1046 1087 344 1126 1238 337 1462 273 58 79 1620 749 1130 1585 1275 630 81 470 1191 527 850 1621 566 937 1059 1114 97 1327 1075 398 1104 1302 758 215 506